Class 4 Shingles and Your Texas Insurance Discount

Class 4 impact resistant shingles and Texas insurance credits

If you have replaced a roof in Garland in the last decade, somebody has used the words “Class 4” on you.

It usually comes with a promise attached. Upgrade to impact-resistant shingles and your insurance company will give you a discount that pays for the upgrade.

The first half of that is true and worth understanding properly. The second half depends entirely on your carrier, and the person telling you otherwise does not know what your carrier does.

Here is how it actually works in Texas.

The rating system

Impact resistance is graded in classes. The Texas Department of Insurance maintains a page on products qualifying for impact-resistant roofing credits, and it describes roofing classified as Class 1, 2, 3 or 4.

Class 4 is the top of the scale. In TDI’s words, “A Class 4 roof covering would receive the highest premium credit.”

To qualify at all, the material has to be tested for impact resistance at a test laboratory under a recognized test standard. The standard most people encounter on a shingle wrapper is UL 2218, which is the test the Texas Windstorm Insurance Association specifically requires for its credit.

The test itself is blunt in a satisfying way. Steel balls are dropped on the material from a set height and the surface is examined for cracking. A Class 4 product withstands the largest ball without the mat fracturing.

That is a laboratory test, not a weather forecast. Which leads to the most important thing in this article.

What Class 4 does and does not promise

Impact-resistant shingles resist cracking and granule loss from hail better than standard shingles. In a hail market like North Texas, that is a real durability advantage over the life of the roof.

They are not hail proof. A large enough stone, at a bad enough angle, will still damage a Class 4 roof. They also do not prevent cosmetic denting on soft metals like vents, gutters and flashing, which is frequently what an adjuster photographs first.

TDI is careful on this point too. Its page notes that the department “does not endorse or recommend any roofing material.”

So the honest case for Class 4 is a longer roof life and fewer claims over time, not immunity. If someone tells you a Class 4 roof will never be damaged again, they have oversold it.

The discount is real, and it is not a number anyone can quote you

This is where most of the bad information lives.

TDI is specific: “The amount of discount for each class of roofing material is established by the insurance company on a company-by-company basis.”

Read that again before you let a salesperson put a percentage in your head. There is no statewide Class 4 discount. There is no rate your neighbor got that you are guaranteed to get. Carriers set their own credits, and they differ.

TDI’s page also does not describe any requirement that insurers offer the credit at all. The language is permissive. Materials may be eligible.

What that means for you is practical. Before you pay for the upgrade, call your own agent and ask two questions. Do you offer a credit for impact-resistant roofing, and what is it on my policy at my address.

Ten minutes on the phone turns a sales claim into a number you can actually do math with.

The paperwork that decides whether you get it

A Class 4 roof with no documentation is a Class 4 roof with no discount. This is where homeowners lose the credit they paid for.

Per TDI, each insurer decides the paperwork that must be submitted by the contractor and the policyholder. Some accept a standard form. Some want their own.

The one codified example is TWIA, the Texas Windstorm Insurance Association, which covers coastal windstorm risk. For a TWIA credit the contractor completes TDI form PC068, the Impact-Resistant Roofing Installation Form, which goes to the policyholder or agent and then to TWIA.

Garland is not TWIA territory, so that specific form is not your path. Mention it to an agent in Dallas County and you may get a blank look. But it is a useful illustration of the level of documentation carriers can ask for, and your carrier may want something comparable.

TWIA’s labeling requirement is also worth knowing, because the underlying principle travels. The product has to carry a label showing the testing lab, the class under UL 2218, the manufacturer, the year of manufacture, and the brand name. Products that meet the standard but lack that labeling do not qualify.

Translated for your project: keep the wrappers, or make sure your contractor photographs the labels and gives you the documentation package. Ask for it in writing before work starts, not after the dumpster is gone.

Is the upgrade worth it in Garland?

Run it as arithmetic rather than a slogan.

On one side, the cost difference between a standard architectural shingle and a Class 4 product on your square footage. Your contractor can give you that number for your specific roof.

On the other side, three things. The annual credit your carrier actually quoted you, multiplied over the years you expect to stay. The likelihood of fewer claims, which matters because claim history affects what you pay and whether you stay insurable. And the longer practical service life in a hail corridor.

We wrote about the durability side of that math in how long a roof lasts in North Texas by material, and about why this area is harder on roofs than most in why Garland roofs age faster than most.

For a lot of Garland homeowners the upgrade pencils out. For some it does not. The number that decides it comes from your agent, not from us and not from a door knocker.

Before you commit

Call your agent and get the credit in writing for your policy.

Confirm in your contract that the product is Class 4 under a recognized test standard, named by manufacturer and product line.

Agree up front on who provides the documentation and labels, and get it delivered at completion.

Then decide.

If you want a straight quote comparing standard and Class 4 on your roof, with no pressure attached to either, call Texas Roofing Project at 214-600-7661 or request a free inspection. You can also run rough numbers yourself with our roofing calculator before you talk to anyone.

This post is general information, not insurance advice. Credits, eligibility and documentation requirements vary by insurer and change over time. Confirm the details with your own agent and with the Texas Department of Insurance.

Written by

Steve Madison Jr., Co-Founder, Texas Roofing Project

Steve has over 12 years of construction experience, from restoration to roofing. A Texas A&M graduate, husband, and father of four, he built his career on genuine relationships and solving real problems for homeowners across North Texas. Read our story.

Explore More